by Shari
The latest New York Times article from William Broad Women’s Flexibility is a Liability (in Yoga) sparked a conversation between Nina and me, both whom are long-term yoga practitioners who have grappled with orthopedic injuries. Broad states that he has recently learned that women are at higher risk of hip injuries in a yoga class because of their inherent flexibility compared to men. He quotes a single yoga teacher, Michaelle Edwards, saying that “women’s elasticity became a liability when extreme bends resulted in serious wear and tear on their hips. Over time the chronic stress could develop into agonizing pain and, in some cases, the need for urgent hip repairs.” He also says of arthritis researchers:
The investigators found that extreme leg motions could cause the hip bones to repeatedly strike each other, leading over time to damaged cartilage, inflammation, pain and crippling arthritis. They called it Femoroacetabular Impingement — or F.A.I., in medical shorthand. The name spoke to a recurrence in which the neck of the thigh bone (the femur) swung so close to the hip socket (the acetabulum) that it repeatedly struck the socket’s protruding rim.
I personally can’t stand sensationalism of any type and particularly sensationalism of the fear and scare tactics kind. When I first saw this article, I groaned inwardly. But I then proceeded to read it carefully, including the related links, and then went on to do some additional research of my own. After all that, my response is: maybe.
First of all, I, as a long-term yoga practitioner, am not sure what exactly he means. We all can be overly flexible in some areas of our bodies and conversely overly tight in other areas of our bodies. The biomechanical model of structure and function is a beautiful yin and yang interplay between forces that influence our bodies, and yes, can ultimately change our structure and function. Some changes may not be as beneficial as others so we need to be consciously selective and astute to observe what changes occur with function.
I also think, as in the past, Broad is careless in his citations of his evidence and is vague about these ER records of hip injuries. However, he does cite some orthopedists and one international study that do substantiate his observation that women who put their hips into extreme ranges of motion can injure their hips. Well, this is blatantly obvious to anyone who may be neurologically intact. When a joint is taken into an extreme position there is a pain response recognized by the central nervous system that warns the person to back off. Of course, if we choose to ignore the pain response, then is it the yoga that is causing the injury or is it the person who is foolishly not listening to the feedback their body is providing?
I also think that to address William Broad’s assertion that women are more flexible than men, we need a better working definition of (biomechanical) flexibility:
Flexibility is the range of motion in a joint or group of joints, or, the ability to move joints effectively. Flexibility is related to muscle strength. Flexibility is also the ability to move through a full range of motion.
Flexibility is a conscious movement that has an intricate feedback mechanism between the muscles and the nerves innervating the muscles and the joints and the central nervous system. There are significant protective mechanisms that prevent the individual from overstretching if they PAY ATTENTION to the sensation of pain rather than ignoring it.
So are women “inherently” more flexible than men? Well, it depends who you ask. But all sports attract a body type, and if yoga is considered a “sport” then there is a body type that is drawn to yoga. We all like to do things that are “easy” and for some flexible bodies yoga is “easy.” The rub here is that this isn’t “yoga” but athleticism masquerading as yoga!
So now let us look at his assertion that yoga is the root cause of “femoracetabular impingement”. The literature that I read, including one of his references, states that the subjective symptoms are deep anterior groin pain with associated intermittent catching and locking of the hip joint. In addition, there is a significant decrease in hip internal rotation. The morphology is that there is a breakdown of the hip labrum (how the head of the femur is connected into the cup of the pelvic acetabulum) and the articular surfaces of the femur and acetabulum. There is a structural change in how the head of the femur is sitting and facing, and movement of the hip will continue to tear the tissue structures with a loosening of the integrity of the hip joint. The problem is that a lot of individuals who have this condition are pain free, asymptomatic and don’t know they have it. The concern is that this condition may be a precursor to developing hip arthritis down the road. There are four types of femoracetabular impingement and one type is more common in women and one type more common in men!
Another article that I read stated that the condition is caused by internal rotation of the hip while in 90 degrees of hip flexion. Yes, this can be Uttanasana (Standing Forward Bend)! So is the problem the combination of these two movements? I don’t know, but does that mean you need to stop doing Uttanasana? I don’t think so unless it is causing pain. And, yes, there are some pretty extreme hip positions in yoga which only some of could do when we were younger (maybe can still do them now) but the bottom line is that we need to practice with intention and attention to form, function and our own bodies' abilities and not soldier on through the pain. Yoga, as we have mentioned time and time again, can be physically and mentally challenging, but is not supposed to hurt. So don’t be scared off again by a sensational journalist who claims he is a yogi.
In a future post I would like to present some of the inherent differences between male and female pelvis and hips that might also help to put into perspective the allegation of the differences between men and women.
Thursday, November 7, 2013
Wednesday, November 6, 2013
New at the Castro store!!!
Stone Double Bastard 2013 $8.99
Stone Quingenti Millitre 2013 Series: Southern Charred
(2012 Double Bastard aged in bourbon barrels) $19.99
Crime (Lukcy Basartd w/ hot peppers & aged in bourbon barrels) $19.99
Punishment (2013 Double Bastard w/ hot peppers & aged in bourbon barrels) $19.99
Bear Republic Racer X $8.99
Clown Shoes Clementine (4 pack) $11.99
Yoga Props: An Introduction
by Nina
Just the other day, I got this interesting request for information on using props.
Another local yoga instructor and I live in a remote/rural area, and attending high quality trainings is difficult at best. We've been looking for a training that focuses on the use of props, but we've had no luck. We are wondering if you could address in your blog, or recommend a good book, about the use of props for seniors. We are looking to create a more supportive class for seniors without taking them straight to a chair.
Well, dear reader, you’re in luck. Because it just so happens that I was trained in the Iyengar style of yoga, and, in fact, the use of props is a modern invention generally credited to B.K.S. Iyengar himself! As the story goes, at the age of 18 (1937), Iyengar was sent by his guru, Krishnamacharya, to Pune to spread the teaching of yoga to “householders .” Observing that his new students—typically older and stiffer than the boys Iyengar had been training with at the Mysore Palace—were often unable to find a healthy and comfortable alignment in the yoga asanas, Iyengar came up with the idea of using props, including blocks (called “bricks” in India), blankets, straps, bolsters, chairs and others, to help support the students in their poses. Ideally using a prop helps you achieve correct alignment in the pose when your body is not open enough or strong enough to do the pose without the prop. Here’s a photo of Baxter doing Triangle pose with his hand on a block instead of the floor. (To be completely honest, Baxter has tight hamstrings and these prevent him—along with a lot of other folks out there—from being able to do Triangle pose with his hand touching the floor.)
I’m telling you all this because your best bet for learning how to use props from a teacher is to find an Iyengar yoga teacher (either official certified Iyengar or Iyengar-style), though I expect by now a lot of other types of teachers have adopted them, too. For those of you who don’t have access to a teacher who is an expert at using props, we do have some information on using props on the blog. Our restorative yoga poses, supported inverted poses, and supported forward bends all use them.
I also wrote a post Making Your Own Yoga Props that provides tips for using simple household items (such as books and sashes and bags of rice) in place of “official props.” And, inspired by this reader’s question, I’ll try to write more about props in the coming weeks.
In the meantime, you can learn from using props from yoga books. I’m going to be very bold and recommend one I co-wrote: Moving Toward Balance, the second yoga book I wrote with Rodney Yee. The reason I’m recommending this one is that we both put a lot of thought into how we presented the information on using props in this book. We included a very thorough overview of the types and purposes of props in the chapter “Preparing to Practice,” which even tells you how to fold yoga blankets! And we systematically provided an easy alternative for every single pose in the book, many of which use props. We also tried to keep the use of props very streamlined and simple because we were concerned that for people practicing at home, needing a large number of props to do a pose could be off-putting. Although these “easy” versions of the poses weren’t designed especially for seniors, I think you’ll find many of them totally appropriate versions that are in between the full version of the pose and doing yoga on a chair. And even the ones that don’t use props (such as the easy version of Warrior 2, which has hands on the hips and an only slightly bent knee) will be very suitable for older beginners.
I’ll also recommend The Woman’s Book of Yoga and Health, my most frequently used yoga book. The last section of the book, which is for older women, has some great examples of yoga poses done with props.
You can see classic Iyengar propping in Iyengar’s book Yoga, The Path to Holistic Health. Some of the propping in this book will be very useful to you, though some, well, may just be too complex and/or elaborate. The elaborate setups tend to be employed in specially equipped yoga studios by Iyengar teachers who are trained in their use.
Once you get into the swing of using props, you may find that you are coming up with your own inventions! My own teacher is constantly coming up with new ideas, which stem out of his personal practice. And I myself have come up with a few nifty ideas….
Just the other day, I got this interesting request for information on using props.
Another local yoga instructor and I live in a remote/rural area, and attending high quality trainings is difficult at best. We've been looking for a training that focuses on the use of props, but we've had no luck. We are wondering if you could address in your blog, or recommend a good book, about the use of props for seniors. We are looking to create a more supportive class for seniors without taking them straight to a chair.
Well, dear reader, you’re in luck. Because it just so happens that I was trained in the Iyengar style of yoga, and, in fact, the use of props is a modern invention generally credited to B.K.S. Iyengar himself! As the story goes, at the age of 18 (1937), Iyengar was sent by his guru, Krishnamacharya, to Pune to spread the teaching of yoga to “householders .” Observing that his new students—typically older and stiffer than the boys Iyengar had been training with at the Mysore Palace—were often unable to find a healthy and comfortable alignment in the yoga asanas, Iyengar came up with the idea of using props, including blocks (called “bricks” in India), blankets, straps, bolsters, chairs and others, to help support the students in their poses. Ideally using a prop helps you achieve correct alignment in the pose when your body is not open enough or strong enough to do the pose without the prop. Here’s a photo of Baxter doing Triangle pose with his hand on a block instead of the floor. (To be completely honest, Baxter has tight hamstrings and these prevent him—along with a lot of other folks out there—from being able to do Triangle pose with his hand touching the floor.)
Triangle Pose with Block (on highest height) |
I also wrote a post Making Your Own Yoga Props that provides tips for using simple household items (such as books and sashes and bags of rice) in place of “official props.” And, inspired by this reader’s question, I’ll try to write more about props in the coming weeks.
In the meantime, you can learn from using props from yoga books. I’m going to be very bold and recommend one I co-wrote: Moving Toward Balance, the second yoga book I wrote with Rodney Yee. The reason I’m recommending this one is that we both put a lot of thought into how we presented the information on using props in this book. We included a very thorough overview of the types and purposes of props in the chapter “Preparing to Practice,” which even tells you how to fold yoga blankets! And we systematically provided an easy alternative for every single pose in the book, many of which use props. We also tried to keep the use of props very streamlined and simple because we were concerned that for people practicing at home, needing a large number of props to do a pose could be off-putting. Although these “easy” versions of the poses weren’t designed especially for seniors, I think you’ll find many of them totally appropriate versions that are in between the full version of the pose and doing yoga on a chair. And even the ones that don’t use props (such as the easy version of Warrior 2, which has hands on the hips and an only slightly bent knee) will be very suitable for older beginners.
I’ll also recommend The Woman’s Book of Yoga and Health, my most frequently used yoga book. The last section of the book, which is for older women, has some great examples of yoga poses done with props.
You can see classic Iyengar propping in Iyengar’s book Yoga, The Path to Holistic Health. Some of the propping in this book will be very useful to you, though some, well, may just be too complex and/or elaborate. The elaborate setups tend to be employed in specially equipped yoga studios by Iyengar teachers who are trained in their use.
Once you get into the swing of using props, you may find that you are coming up with your own inventions! My own teacher is constantly coming up with new ideas, which stem out of his personal practice. And I myself have come up with a few nifty ideas….
Tuesday, November 5, 2013
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and Yoga
by Baxter
As we once again pass through the man-made time shift that is daylight savings time (ughh!), I always notice a general malaise and sluggishness in many of my students. The frequency with which my folks report colds and flu goes way up, and the request for longer Savasana at the end of class is a regular phenomenon. But on occasion, a student will report ongoing fatigue that goes way beyond the seasonal shifts or illness exposure of the fall and winter season. Some of these students return from a visit to their doctor with a tentative diagnosis of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS).
It is very likely you know someone with this condition. According to a 2003 study in the Annals of Internal Medicine, the prevalence—the total number of cases of a disease in a given population at a specific time—of CFS is 235 per 100,000 people, with women three times more likely to develop CFS than men.
But just being tired a lot does not get you the diagnosis of CFS. The Mayo Clinic defines chronic fatigue syndrome as:
“a complicated disorder characterized by extreme fatigue that can't be explained by any underlying medical condition. The fatigue may worsen with physical or mental activity, but doesn't improve with rest.”
In fact you have to have significant fatigue for at least 6 months, along with 4 of the following other signs or symptoms, according to the Mayo Clinic:
Patients with CFS can a lot of variability in their symptoms, with some days better than others, and flares of symptoms can happen with minor increases in activity. However, because the condition does not get better with rest, the recommendations for treatment by your doctor will include medications, physical therapy and lifestyle modifications. Encouragingly, the Mayo Clinic site actually recommends yoga to help manage the pain symptoms of CFS. And although the studies of the effects of yoga for CFS are yet to be done, the Centers for Disease Control does recommend yoga as a part of treatment approach for CFS.
Many of the yoga recommendations I have made for other chronic illness would apply here as well. Start out slowly, with small, gentle yoga practices, even done in bed. Working with an experienced teacher or yoga therapist initially will give you the greatest chance of gaining benefits from adding yoga to your treatment. Since yoga has been shown in studies to have benefits for stress reduction (an aggravating factor for CFS), and improvements in both endocrine and immune function, systems that can be out of balance in CFS, yoga will likely affect more than just the pain symptoms.
And, as we always advocate here at YFHA, “yoga” implies using as many of the tools of yoga as are appropriate for each individual. If you added in an Ayurvedic perspective, attention to diet and sleep would be included in as well. And on days when a more active physical practice seems daunting or counterproductive, breath work, guided imagery and meditation, including yoga nidra, will allow you to still “practice.” Just the ability to do some sort of practice regularly can give the person with CFS a greater sense of control over their health, which can foster a greater sense of healing and improve their outlook. And as the student progresses to greater levels of ability with the physical poses, which a physical therapist would refer to as “graded exercise,” attendance in a gentle yoga class would be recommended to combat the tendency to social isolation that can often accompanies the lives of those with CFS. Due to the uncertainty of how long CFS may be around, establishing a yoga practice as an ongoing, daily part of your life will have benefits far beyond its effect on only one aspect of your health.
If any of our readers have personal experiences with the pros and cons of yoga for CFS, please write in and share this valuable information with your fellow YFHA readers. Thanks!
Floating Leaves by Melina Meza |
It is very likely you know someone with this condition. According to a 2003 study in the Annals of Internal Medicine, the prevalence—the total number of cases of a disease in a given population at a specific time—of CFS is 235 per 100,000 people, with women three times more likely to develop CFS than men.
But just being tired a lot does not get you the diagnosis of CFS. The Mayo Clinic defines chronic fatigue syndrome as:
“a complicated disorder characterized by extreme fatigue that can't be explained by any underlying medical condition. The fatigue may worsen with physical or mental activity, but doesn't improve with rest.”
In fact you have to have significant fatigue for at least 6 months, along with 4 of the following other signs or symptoms, according to the Mayo Clinic:
- loss of memory or concentration
- sore throat
- enlarged lymph nodes in your neck or armpit
- unexplained muscle pain
- pain that moves from one joint to another without swelling or redness
- headache of a new type, pattern or severity
- unrefreshing sleep
- extreme exhaustion lasting more than 24 hours after physical or mental exercise
Patients with CFS can a lot of variability in their symptoms, with some days better than others, and flares of symptoms can happen with minor increases in activity. However, because the condition does not get better with rest, the recommendations for treatment by your doctor will include medications, physical therapy and lifestyle modifications. Encouragingly, the Mayo Clinic site actually recommends yoga to help manage the pain symptoms of CFS. And although the studies of the effects of yoga for CFS are yet to be done, the Centers for Disease Control does recommend yoga as a part of treatment approach for CFS.
Many of the yoga recommendations I have made for other chronic illness would apply here as well. Start out slowly, with small, gentle yoga practices, even done in bed. Working with an experienced teacher or yoga therapist initially will give you the greatest chance of gaining benefits from adding yoga to your treatment. Since yoga has been shown in studies to have benefits for stress reduction (an aggravating factor for CFS), and improvements in both endocrine and immune function, systems that can be out of balance in CFS, yoga will likely affect more than just the pain symptoms.
And, as we always advocate here at YFHA, “yoga” implies using as many of the tools of yoga as are appropriate for each individual. If you added in an Ayurvedic perspective, attention to diet and sleep would be included in as well. And on days when a more active physical practice seems daunting or counterproductive, breath work, guided imagery and meditation, including yoga nidra, will allow you to still “practice.” Just the ability to do some sort of practice regularly can give the person with CFS a greater sense of control over their health, which can foster a greater sense of healing and improve their outlook. And as the student progresses to greater levels of ability with the physical poses, which a physical therapist would refer to as “graded exercise,” attendance in a gentle yoga class would be recommended to combat the tendency to social isolation that can often accompanies the lives of those with CFS. Due to the uncertainty of how long CFS may be around, establishing a yoga practice as an ongoing, daily part of your life will have benefits far beyond its effect on only one aspect of your health.
If any of our readers have personal experiences with the pros and cons of yoga for CFS, please write in and share this valuable information with your fellow YFHA readers. Thanks!
Monday, November 4, 2013
Finishing the Year Strong Update & Tex Mex Casserole with Egg Noodles
We last talked about our goal of finishing 2013 healthy and strong and I so appreciate your feedback in the comments. Your courage to share where you are in your journey helps me be transparent in mine too and I feel like we're in this together. I got in 4 really great workouts last week, and I feel that that's a good fit for my current schedule through the end of the year. It takes some planning and preparation to make sure to get to the gym, but if I workout hard for at least 50 minutes, I'm good with 4 days.
Getting started back into a weight-lifting/workout routine is especially hard because you are so SORE for the first few days. I had to take Advil a few times, but I'm already fine. And isn't it funny how after just a few workouts you feel 5 pounds lighter?! My scale says I'm down half a pound. It's a start!
On Halloween, I ate 2 chocolate chip cookies that a mom from my son's school made and a mini Reese's Peanut Butter cup. To be honest, the cookies were delicious, but I should have just had one, and the Reese's didn't taste that good- probably because I'm a PB cup snob now, having fallen in love with the homemade variety. The point is, if I'm going to "cheat" I want it to be worth it! And I know that finishing the year strong requires some sacrifice and diligence with my food especially during the week. So, I'm being more conscious of what foods I'm choosing and having something really good to look forward to on the weekend. On Saturday night, we went out to a great restaurant and I ate oxtails and potatoes- so good, but really rich, so I only ate about 1/3 of what was on my plate. I had 2 glasses of wine and for dessert, had a big ole ice cream cone that I really enjoyed. Back on the wagon for Monday.
My other tip for this week is to SHARE MEALS when you go out to eat, if possible. I'm usually full after half my meal, but feel like I need to finish, so I'll end up eating too much. Leftovers from restaurants usually end up in the trash and it's a shame to waste the food and money. Sharing with someone eliminates that and you don't leave the table feeling so heavy from overeating.
I made a healthy meal last week that I think you might like too. I warn you that it's not the prettiest dish, but very tasty and full of protein. It's kind of a Tex-Mex casserole with egg noodles. I really believe that "abs are made in the kitchen", which is why the eating portion is so crucial to seeing results. My meals last week pretty much consisted of:
7am- oatmeal and coffee
10am- protein shake
12pm- this casserole
3pm- tuna sandwich and Sun chips
6pm- this casserole
8pm- Greek yogurt or hot cocoa
I also stopped in Starbucks a few times (which is a step back from my previous daily addiction).
Ingredients
1 Jennie O- Extra Lean Ground Turkey
1 Laura's Lean Beef (94% Lean) - or go leaner
1 bag No Yolk Egg Noodles
1/2 container of Philadelphia Cream Cheese (1/3 less fat) - or use fat free
1 cup Shredded Mexican cheese (2%) - or use fat free
1 package Taco Seasoning (low sodium)
Directions
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Boil the egg noodles for about 8 minutes, then drain.
Meanwhile, brown the two meats until cooked though, add the seasoning mix with about a cup of water and let it boil until the water and seasoning is absorbed.
Off the heat, add the cream cheese and 1/2 cup of shredded cheese to the meat mixture and stir until all melted and mixed in. Add in the noodles and stir until combined.
Pour the entire thing into a 9x13 baking dish, top with remaining 1/2 cup of shredded cheese. Bake for about 20 minutes.
I based this dish on a pin from Pinterest, but lightened it up. To make it even lighter, use leaner beef and fat free cream cheese and fat free shredded cheese. Some people may also like to add salsa to this for more flavor.
If you portion this dish into 10 servings, below is the nutrition information. I use myfitnesspal.com to calculate the nutrition- it's free and really user-friendly.
So, how's it going for you? If you've fallen off the wagon, just get back on!
via Nike
___________
Breathing, Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, and Yoga
by Shari
In my “day job” as a home health physical therapist, I see a lot of clients who have significant breathing difficulties. One of the most common breathing ailments is Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). COPD is similar to asthma in that some of the symptoms are the same but the etiology of the disease is different. Most significant is the inability to get air out and not being able to get enough oxygen in.
Let me give you a bit of background about breathing and normal airways. Air travels into the lungs via the trachea. It goes down a series of branching airways called bronchi. These bronchi branch into smaller bronchioles and then into millions of tiny air sacs called alveoli. Oxygen in the air passes through the thin walls of the alveoli into the tiny blood vessels nearby, attaches to red blood cells and is carried into the blood vessels to the rest of the body. Carbon dioxide is passed out into the alveoli from the red blood cells and is breathed out. But breathing doesn’t always depend upon the oxygen needs of the body. Breathing can be related to emotions, body tension, sensations of pain, pleasure, and body movements.
Breathing is composed of two main parts: inhalation and exhalation. Inhalation is the process of taking air into the lungs. It can occur with different amplitudes or volume of air. It can occur at a variable rate, and it can be less active. Exhalation is the process of letting air flow from the lungs back outside the body. It can vary in amplitude, rate and effort. You can stop your breathing but, of course, not permanently.
There are two main types of breathing: costal (ribs) breathing and diaphragmatic breathing. In costal breathing the ribs open and close primarily and in diaphragmatic breathing the abdomen changes shape.
The volume of air that one breathes in inhalation is called “tidal volume” and in rest or relaxation it is at a minimum. When we do moderate activity, we increase the amount of air that is bought into the lungs but this doesn’t change the tidal volume. When we maximally exhale the air from our lungs, there is always some air left in the lungs and this is called residual volume.
Other factors that influence the depth of our breath include rib cage flexibility, (the more flexible the rib cage, the more we can increase the amplitude of our inhalation) and muscular strength of the muscles of exhalation. The diaphragm is the primary muscle of inspiration. The secondary or accessory muscles of respiration include many muscles of the ribs, neck, chest wall, and trunk (abdominal muscles).
When we breathe, the diaphragm contracts and moves downward if the abdomen is relaxed. The belly will then gently expand outward and the lower regions of the lungs expand downward. When we exhale, the diaphragm relaxes and moves back up, the belly moves in a bit.
An individual with COPD works very hard to breathe. Often there are postural changes that occur over time that may be structurally compromising the ability of the rib cage to expand and return to resting position. If the anterior chest wall is collapsed and tight, then we don’t have the rib or thoracic flexibility to encourage the lungs to fill to their capacity. Breathing involves muscles, skeletal and joint articulations and is an interface of organs and movement. But breathing is also an emotional activity.
Because an individual with COPD is chronically short of breath, they fear movement because it makes them short of breath, so in turn they become chronically deconditioned, and weak due to immobility. The fear of not being able to breathe leads to increased anxiety, depression and more fatigue and stress. Here is where the practice of therapeutic yoga can be so beneficial for an individual with COPD.
If we consider the individual fully and address their physical, emotional, neurological and spiritual nature, we can assist them in learning to move again within the confines of managing their respiratory issues. Learning to observe one’s breathing pattern and to gently try to increase the exhalation compared to the inhalation is quite beneficial for someone with COPD. Gentle asana practice that addresses areas of chronic tightness and postural awareness with improved skeletal flexibility allows more freedom of respiratory movement. Please see all our wonderful prior posts for gentle seated practices and safe gentle yoga poses. Also please reread the pranayama posts because these can be adapted to a COPD breathing pattern if the emphasis is on the exhalation with no retention holds at either the end of inhalation or exhalation. Lastly, trying to walk with good self pacing and breathing awareness (sort of like a meditation practice) is a wonderful way to begin to address the poor endurance that plagues someone with COPD. If you yourself have COPD or know someone with COPD who wants to study yoga, I would recommend individual private one-on-one yoga sessions to start, and then, if and when possible, moving on to a gentle yoga class that is slow paced.
Note: November 16, 2013, Shari and her colleague, Bonnie Maeda, will be teaching a workshop in Brentwood, California on Yoga for Breathing and Sleep Apnea, which covers COPD and other topics. For further information or to register for the workshop, see brentwoodyogacenter.com.
In my “day job” as a home health physical therapist, I see a lot of clients who have significant breathing difficulties. One of the most common breathing ailments is Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). COPD is similar to asthma in that some of the symptoms are the same but the etiology of the disease is different. Most significant is the inability to get air out and not being able to get enough oxygen in.
Let me give you a bit of background about breathing and normal airways. Air travels into the lungs via the trachea. It goes down a series of branching airways called bronchi. These bronchi branch into smaller bronchioles and then into millions of tiny air sacs called alveoli. Oxygen in the air passes through the thin walls of the alveoli into the tiny blood vessels nearby, attaches to red blood cells and is carried into the blood vessels to the rest of the body. Carbon dioxide is passed out into the alveoli from the red blood cells and is breathed out. But breathing doesn’t always depend upon the oxygen needs of the body. Breathing can be related to emotions, body tension, sensations of pain, pleasure, and body movements.
Breathing is composed of two main parts: inhalation and exhalation. Inhalation is the process of taking air into the lungs. It can occur with different amplitudes or volume of air. It can occur at a variable rate, and it can be less active. Exhalation is the process of letting air flow from the lungs back outside the body. It can vary in amplitude, rate and effort. You can stop your breathing but, of course, not permanently.
There are two main types of breathing: costal (ribs) breathing and diaphragmatic breathing. In costal breathing the ribs open and close primarily and in diaphragmatic breathing the abdomen changes shape.
The volume of air that one breathes in inhalation is called “tidal volume” and in rest or relaxation it is at a minimum. When we do moderate activity, we increase the amount of air that is bought into the lungs but this doesn’t change the tidal volume. When we maximally exhale the air from our lungs, there is always some air left in the lungs and this is called residual volume.
Other factors that influence the depth of our breath include rib cage flexibility, (the more flexible the rib cage, the more we can increase the amplitude of our inhalation) and muscular strength of the muscles of exhalation. The diaphragm is the primary muscle of inspiration. The secondary or accessory muscles of respiration include many muscles of the ribs, neck, chest wall, and trunk (abdominal muscles).
The Diaphragm (with ribs cut away) |
An individual with COPD works very hard to breathe. Often there are postural changes that occur over time that may be structurally compromising the ability of the rib cage to expand and return to resting position. If the anterior chest wall is collapsed and tight, then we don’t have the rib or thoracic flexibility to encourage the lungs to fill to their capacity. Breathing involves muscles, skeletal and joint articulations and is an interface of organs and movement. But breathing is also an emotional activity.
Because an individual with COPD is chronically short of breath, they fear movement because it makes them short of breath, so in turn they become chronically deconditioned, and weak due to immobility. The fear of not being able to breathe leads to increased anxiety, depression and more fatigue and stress. Here is where the practice of therapeutic yoga can be so beneficial for an individual with COPD.
If we consider the individual fully and address their physical, emotional, neurological and spiritual nature, we can assist them in learning to move again within the confines of managing their respiratory issues. Learning to observe one’s breathing pattern and to gently try to increase the exhalation compared to the inhalation is quite beneficial for someone with COPD. Gentle asana practice that addresses areas of chronic tightness and postural awareness with improved skeletal flexibility allows more freedom of respiratory movement. Please see all our wonderful prior posts for gentle seated practices and safe gentle yoga poses. Also please reread the pranayama posts because these can be adapted to a COPD breathing pattern if the emphasis is on the exhalation with no retention holds at either the end of inhalation or exhalation. Lastly, trying to walk with good self pacing and breathing awareness (sort of like a meditation practice) is a wonderful way to begin to address the poor endurance that plagues someone with COPD. If you yourself have COPD or know someone with COPD who wants to study yoga, I would recommend individual private one-on-one yoga sessions to start, and then, if and when possible, moving on to a gentle yoga class that is slow paced.
Note: November 16, 2013, Shari and her colleague, Bonnie Maeda, will be teaching a workshop in Brentwood, California on Yoga for Breathing and Sleep Apnea, which covers COPD and other topics. For further information or to register for the workshop, see brentwoodyogacenter.com.
Friday, November 1, 2013
Friday Q&A: Costochondritis
Q: How can yoga help people that have costochondritis? I have it now and then and I can't do some yoga poses that open the chest as they trigger the pain. I had it for the first time 3 years ago and it never really went away, keeps coming back.
A: Costochondritis (CC) is a fairly common cause of chest wall pain in adults in the US and around the world. According to the Mayo Clinic website:
“Costochondritis (kos-toe-KHON-dri-tis) is an inflammation of the cartilage that connects a rib to the breastbone (sternum) — a junction known as the costosternal joint. Pain caused by costochondritis may mimic that of a heart attack or other heart conditions.”
This last statement about this kind of pain mimicking heart attack has led many a student of mine with sudden onset of chest pain to the hospital, fearful they were having one! In the case of costochondritis, all the tests come up normal, which is obviously a huge relief, but the pain can persist, as it has for our reader.
Let’s look at some other facets of costochondritis before we specifically look at what yoga’s role is in helping or hurting it. Modern medicine’s view on CC is that most of the time there is no apparent cause for the inflammation between the rib and cartilage, which can be frustrating if you have it because if you knew what caused it, you could change what you are doing to possibly avoid it happening again! So the focus shifts to treating the pain, usually with anti-inflammatory medications like ibuprofen, as well as modifying your activities to avoid movements that aggravate your pain. Since most of the connections between the ribs and breastbone involved are located to the right and left side your breast bone, this is usually where the pain shows up. Apparently, it shows up more often on the left side of the breastbone (same area some heart attack pain can be) and often involves more than one rib. One distinguishing feature that sets it apart from heart pain or angina, is that the pain from CC often happens with a deeper breath or when coughing.
And although I mentioned above that most cases of CC have no known cause, some cases are associated with a blow to the chest, heavy lifting or strenuous exercise, severe bouts of coughing, certain types of arthritis, or the spread of tumors to this area. In addition, you are at greater risk of developing a bout of CC if you are woman or if you are over 40 years of age. The diagnosis of CC is usually made when your history is consistent with the kind of pain I described above, if you are tender-to-touch over the side of your breast bone or when you move your chest and arms in certain ways, and if you have ruled out more serious problems, like heart pain, GI reflux or lung related illnesses, like pneumonia. Hopefully, you won’t have to do the ER full heart work up like one of my students had to undergo this past week!
In addition to NSAIDS like ibuprofen, your doc might add other medications to your treatment regimen. If the pain is severe, a narcotic medication might be suggested. If the condition lingers and becomes more chronic (which does not happen often but does happen), certain anti-depressants and anti-seizure medications can be added, not for depression or seizures, but because they have been found useful for chronic pain management. The downside to all these meds is that they often have unwanted and occasionally serious side effects.
On the non-medication side of things your doctor may recommend, you might be referred to a physical therapist, who could teach you gentle stretching exercises (ding, ding, ding!) or the use of an electrical stimulation unit called a TENS unit. On your own, you can experiment with the effect of ice or heat on your symptoms to see if they provide any relief from the pain, as well as good amounts of rest to avoid aggravating activities.
Our reader is interested in how yoga might be used to help costochondritis, but also, I suspect, how to do so cautiously, as she has noticed that the yoga asana can also aggravate or trigger her CC pain. And therein lies the rub. If you are pain free, a regular yoga practice can keep the rib cage and the joints that CC affects mobile and the muscles in the region strong and open. A regular yoga practice has been found to improve conditions that could lead to costochondritis, such as arthritic conditions. And yoga has been found to decease inflammation in those who practice it regularly, so it might help reduce the chances of developing CC in the future.
On the other side of the fence, some forms of yoga and certain yoga poses fall into the category of strenuous exercise or stressful activities for the sternal joints. Dhanurasana (Bow pose) comes to mind as a pose that stresses the joints along the sides of sternum as it stretches the front chest, and a 90-minute power yoga flow with lots of Chatarunga Dandasana could also overtax the front chest joints as well. So you would want to assess if you developed CC within a short time of doing such poses, and give ‘em a rest if you make the connection.
Hopefully, your yoga practice is not the source of this kind of pain. But once costochondritis shows up, you will likely need to assess, monitor and modify your poses and practices if they seem to trigger or aggravate your symptoms. It is almost always a safe bet you can do supported restorative style poses, as they are less likely to negatively affect the front chest if done with the goal of keeping that area quiet. And supported, gentle practices are likely to lower your stress response, which should have a positive impact on healing. They should also allow your immune system to function optimally, thereby reducing the chances of developing new respiratory illness like the common cold, thus avoiding illness associated with coughing. In addition, always think outside the yoga asana box, and add in gentle pranayama (probably not long, deep inhales and exhales for a while), visualizations and meditations in supported positions while the inflammation around the breastbone joints diminishes.
And as the pain symptoms of costochondritis diminish, gradually re-introduce more active poses and practices to get your body back to its previous healthy balance, hopefully leaving the memory and risk of recurrence of costochondritis in your rear-view mirror.
—Baxter
A: Costochondritis (CC) is a fairly common cause of chest wall pain in adults in the US and around the world. According to the Mayo Clinic website:
“Costochondritis (kos-toe-KHON-dri-tis) is an inflammation of the cartilage that connects a rib to the breastbone (sternum) — a junction known as the costosternal joint. Pain caused by costochondritis may mimic that of a heart attack or other heart conditions.”
This last statement about this kind of pain mimicking heart attack has led many a student of mine with sudden onset of chest pain to the hospital, fearful they were having one! In the case of costochondritis, all the tests come up normal, which is obviously a huge relief, but the pain can persist, as it has for our reader.
Let’s look at some other facets of costochondritis before we specifically look at what yoga’s role is in helping or hurting it. Modern medicine’s view on CC is that most of the time there is no apparent cause for the inflammation between the rib and cartilage, which can be frustrating if you have it because if you knew what caused it, you could change what you are doing to possibly avoid it happening again! So the focus shifts to treating the pain, usually with anti-inflammatory medications like ibuprofen, as well as modifying your activities to avoid movements that aggravate your pain. Since most of the connections between the ribs and breastbone involved are located to the right and left side your breast bone, this is usually where the pain shows up. Apparently, it shows up more often on the left side of the breastbone (same area some heart attack pain can be) and often involves more than one rib. One distinguishing feature that sets it apart from heart pain or angina, is that the pain from CC often happens with a deeper breath or when coughing.
And although I mentioned above that most cases of CC have no known cause, some cases are associated with a blow to the chest, heavy lifting or strenuous exercise, severe bouts of coughing, certain types of arthritis, or the spread of tumors to this area. In addition, you are at greater risk of developing a bout of CC if you are woman or if you are over 40 years of age. The diagnosis of CC is usually made when your history is consistent with the kind of pain I described above, if you are tender-to-touch over the side of your breast bone or when you move your chest and arms in certain ways, and if you have ruled out more serious problems, like heart pain, GI reflux or lung related illnesses, like pneumonia. Hopefully, you won’t have to do the ER full heart work up like one of my students had to undergo this past week!
In addition to NSAIDS like ibuprofen, your doc might add other medications to your treatment regimen. If the pain is severe, a narcotic medication might be suggested. If the condition lingers and becomes more chronic (which does not happen often but does happen), certain anti-depressants and anti-seizure medications can be added, not for depression or seizures, but because they have been found useful for chronic pain management. The downside to all these meds is that they often have unwanted and occasionally serious side effects.
On the non-medication side of things your doctor may recommend, you might be referred to a physical therapist, who could teach you gentle stretching exercises (ding, ding, ding!) or the use of an electrical stimulation unit called a TENS unit. On your own, you can experiment with the effect of ice or heat on your symptoms to see if they provide any relief from the pain, as well as good amounts of rest to avoid aggravating activities.
Our reader is interested in how yoga might be used to help costochondritis, but also, I suspect, how to do so cautiously, as she has noticed that the yoga asana can also aggravate or trigger her CC pain. And therein lies the rub. If you are pain free, a regular yoga practice can keep the rib cage and the joints that CC affects mobile and the muscles in the region strong and open. A regular yoga practice has been found to improve conditions that could lead to costochondritis, such as arthritic conditions. And yoga has been found to decease inflammation in those who practice it regularly, so it might help reduce the chances of developing CC in the future.
On the other side of the fence, some forms of yoga and certain yoga poses fall into the category of strenuous exercise or stressful activities for the sternal joints. Dhanurasana (Bow pose) comes to mind as a pose that stresses the joints along the sides of sternum as it stretches the front chest, and a 90-minute power yoga flow with lots of Chatarunga Dandasana could also overtax the front chest joints as well. So you would want to assess if you developed CC within a short time of doing such poses, and give ‘em a rest if you make the connection.
Hopefully, your yoga practice is not the source of this kind of pain. But once costochondritis shows up, you will likely need to assess, monitor and modify your poses and practices if they seem to trigger or aggravate your symptoms. It is almost always a safe bet you can do supported restorative style poses, as they are less likely to negatively affect the front chest if done with the goal of keeping that area quiet. And supported, gentle practices are likely to lower your stress response, which should have a positive impact on healing. They should also allow your immune system to function optimally, thereby reducing the chances of developing new respiratory illness like the common cold, thus avoiding illness associated with coughing. In addition, always think outside the yoga asana box, and add in gentle pranayama (probably not long, deep inhales and exhales for a while), visualizations and meditations in supported positions while the inflammation around the breastbone joints diminishes.
And as the pain symptoms of costochondritis diminish, gradually re-introduce more active poses and practices to get your body back to its previous healthy balance, hopefully leaving the memory and risk of recurrence of costochondritis in your rear-view mirror.
—Baxter
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)